Is It Really Below Market Value? The Fake BMV Mistake

Updated: 6 days ago

Below market value deals are houses bought for less than similar houses nearby have actually sold for. Not less than the asking price. That's the mistake: "asking £120k, secured at £112k" gets sold as 7% below market, when the comparables say £108k to £112k. That's full market value. The fix is three sold comparables, rounded to the nearest £5k, before you call anything BMV.
I'm George Samoila. I run Manchester Sourcing and Guaranteed Rent Hub, and I mentor sourcers, landlords and investors. This is the deal analysis mistake I see most often, and the one that costs sourcers their investors fastest.
What are below market value deals, really?
A below market value deal means the price is lower than what the market has recently paid for the same kind of house in the same place. The market is the sold prices, not the asking price. An asking price is an opinion, often the agent's way of winning the instruction. A sold price is a fact.
So the discount is always measured against comparables. Never against the asking price, and never against what the seller hoped for.
Why is the asking price the wrong yardstick?
Because an asking price can be anything. Here are two deals I've seen dressed up as BMV:
Asking £120k, secured at £112k, "7% BMV": comparables £108k–£112k. What it really is: full market value.
"Agreed at £60k, a bargain": comparables £48k–£52k. What it really is: above market value.
The second one is the dangerous one. The investor pays £60k for a house the valuer will put at about £50k, and finds out when the mortgage valuation comes back short. If their plan was to refinance after a light refurb, the money they expected to pull out isn't there.
Why does this mistake cost sourcers so much?
Because the valuer finds out, and then the investor finds out. A lender's surveyor values the house on sold comparables, the same way you should have. If your deal pack says £130k and the valuation says £112k, you've lost more than the deal. You've lost the investor, and probably anyone they talk to.
It's rarely dishonesty. Usually the sourcer copied the agent's figure, or used one flattering sale from two years ago. The result is the same.
How do you find proper comparables?

Search in this order, and stop when you have at least three good ones:
Sold in the same postcode. Same number of bedrooms, same type of house, similar condition, sold recently. You can search sold prices on GOV.UK's house price search or the portals.
Under offer or for sale in the same postcode. These tell you where the market is heading, but treat them as weaker evidence than sold prices.
The same again within a quarter of a mile, if the postcode is thin.
Then round to the nearest £5k. Valuation isn't precise, and pretending it is fools nobody.
Two more things worth five minutes each:
The listing history. How long has it been on, and how many price drops? A house reduced three times is telling you something.
Street View history. Past works, what's next door, the pylon you didn't notice on the photos.
How do you check a valuation with £ per square metre?
Take the floor area from the house's energy performance certificate and multiply it by the local sold price per square metre. For example, a building of 161 m² in an area selling at £867 per m² comes to about £140k.
It's a cross-check, not a valuation. It catches the deal where the agent's particulars quietly overstate the size, and it flatters nothing.
What else makes a deal look better than it is?
The discount is the headline, but the numbers underneath can mislead just as easily. Two habits to drop:
Using a mortgage rate nobody can get. Run the return on today's rate, with a full list of costs, including maintenance and the boiler.
Folding capital growth into the return. Growth is never guaranteed. If you mention it, say it separately and say that.
I wrote about the bigger picture of picking where you buy in choosing your sourcing patch. Knowing your patch street by street is what makes comparables quick: after a few months, you'll know the right number before you look it up.
What this means for you
If you're a sourcer, take your last five deals and redo the discount against three sold comparables each. If the BMV figure shrinks, change how you write your deal packs this week. Show the comparables on the page. Investors trust a deal more when they can check it.
Then apply the integrity test: would you buy this yourself, or recommend it to someone you care about? If not, don't send it.
If you're a landlord or investor, ask whoever sources for you one question: "Which three sales is that discount based on?" A good sourcer has the answer ready. If you get the asking price back, you've got your answer too.
This is one of the 12 modules in the Field Manual every mentee gets.
FAQ
How do you know if a property is really below market value? Compare the price with at least three recent sold prices for the same type of house, with the same bedrooms and condition, in the same postcode or within a quarter of a mile. Round to the nearest £5k. If the price is under that figure, it's below market value. The asking price doesn't count.
Is a discount off the asking price the same as BMV? No. Asking prices are often set high to win the instruction or leave room to negotiate. A house secured at £8k under the asking price can still be at full market value, or even above it, if nearby houses sold for less. Only sold comparables tell you the market value.
How many comparables do I need? At least three, and the closer the better: same street or postcode first, then within a quarter of a mile. Same type, bedrooms and condition, and sold recently. One flattering sale isn't evidence. If you can't find three, say so in the deal pack rather than stretching the search.
What happens if the mortgage valuation comes in lower than the price? The lender lends on its own valuation, so the investor has to put in more cash, renegotiate or walk away. It's why the discount must be measured against comparables from the start. For anything legal in the contract, such as pulling out, the investor should speak to their solicitor.
Talk it through
Not sure where you're stuck? Take the 3-minute quiz: what type of property operator are you?
If you're sourcing already and want help tightening your deal analysis, book a Mentoring Call.



Comments